Extemporaneous Prayer vs. Written PrayerIs one better than the other? Like many conservative evangelical Christians I grew up in in a church that strongly encouraged extemporaneous prayer but seemed suspicious of written prayers – or at least, that was my impression. We never used them in public worship services and I certainly don’t recall any encouragement to use written prayers in private. It was as if extemporaneous praying was sincere and devout while written prayers were somehow cold and dead. But is this true? Today there remains two distinct camps on this matter. Those only in favor of extemporaneous prayer point to the Sermon on the Mount where the Lord Jesus warned: "And when you pray, do not heap up empty phrases…" (Matthew 6:7, ESV) The implication being that all written prayers, regularly recited amount to little more than “empty phrases” (ESV) or as the KJV more forcefully puts it, “vain repetitions.” And there certainly is danger here, isn’t there? In Greek the phrase in Matthew 6:7 describes prayers that are “tediously stammered.” But when Jesus warned against prayers tediously stammered was He really referring to written prayers? That is to say, when He spoke the words of Matthew 6:7 was He turning aside from the main thrust of His Sermon on the Mount to offer a few pointers about the merits of extemporaneous prayer over against written prayers? It hardly seems likely considering in the very next breath He gave us the most oft recited “written” prayer of all time: "Our Father which art in heaven, Hallowed be thy name. Thy kingdom come. Thy will be done in earth, as it is in heaven. Give us this day our daily bread. And forgive us our debts, as we forgive our debtors. And lead us not into temptation, but deliver us from evil: For thine is the kingdom, and the power, and the glory, for ever. Amen. " (Matthew 6:9-13, KJV) To my mind this at least suggests that both written and extemporaneous prayers are useful for us. Therefore, in recent years I have made personal use of both particularly in my morning devotions. I would encourage you to do the same. The question arises: Where can I find some written prayers to pray? Some written prayers can be found in the Bible (eg. Exodus 33:13, Psalm 51:1-8, Jonah 2:2-9, & Philippians 1:9-11) while other non-inspired prayers are recorded for us in very helpful prayer books like The Valley of Vision (purchase a copy if you don’t already have one). Though these prayers are “written” they need not be seen only as “tedious stammering,” in fact, you are feel free to add extemporaneous elements to them. You can make these prayers your own and rework them to suit your current situation. If you are like me and are keenly aware that you often do not know how to pray as you ought (Romans 8:26) these written prayers can act as very helpful guides. In using them you will not only deepen your understanding of the how-to’s of prayer but you will also add direction and intentionality to your conversations with God. Over the past several month I have been using a modified version of “The Litany” from the Book of Common Prayer. I have recorded it below and would encourage you to use it if it would be helpful to you.“The Litany” |
Rev. R Crabtree"...a son, a husband, a father of 6, a friend, a Presbyterian Archives
November 2022
Categories
All
|

RSS Feed